
Then came his digital period, imitating Andy Warhol, welcomed by critics with the solemnity of defrocked priests discovering a new relic. Toward a world where painting becomes a file, where the gesture is reduced to a caress across an iPad’s tempered glass, where the artwork arrives already prepared to be printed on mugs or scarves. Since Lascaux, artists had struggled against matter itself. Hockney, meanwhile, found a way to eliminate it. What progress! Painting once possessed the thickness of earth and oil, the smell of turpentine and accumulated time. With Hockney, even the tragedy of the gesture disappears, leaving behind an image that is perfectly exportable, perfectly marketable, perfectly compatible with the museum gift shop. As for the portraits, the ultimate refuge of the master’s defenders, they undeniably possess elegance.
Everything is in its proper place, and the sitters seem condemned to an eternity of good manners. One admires the composition as one admires a perfectly arranged shop window. But where is the vertigo? Even the soul itself appears to have been given instructions on how to behave. Ultimately, his immense success may tell us less about the story of a genius than about the story of an era. An era that prefers images to painting, reproduction to experience, communication to creation, comfort to disturbance. Hockney is the ideal artist for a world that wants color without risk, art without discomfort, prestige without difficulty. He has become the great painter of a civilization that sometimes mistakes a masterpiece for an exceptionally successful wallpaper or screensaver.
And that is precisely why he triumphs. Because he almost never unsettles. Because he is immediately likable. Because he transforms culture into a smiling luxury product. In short, David Hockney may well be the greatest decorator of our time. Whether he is the greatest living painter remains an open question. But one thing is certain: if the history of art were ever replaced by a chain of five-star hotels, he would undoubtedly be its patron saint.